Alternative Weekend: Was 'Calling All Stations' Really That Bad?

in hive-193816 •  4 months ago  (edited)

Lately, I have been listening to the Genesis album that nobody was interested in hearing, 'Calling All Stations'.


In 1996 Phil Collins left the Genesis, and the rest of the band recruited former Stilskin and Scottish singer Ray Wilson to be their vocalist.

There is plenty of history on the internet how Mike Rutherford wanted to call it a day after the whole US tour was cancelled due to lack of interest, and the ‘bad treatment’ Wilson received, but I’m focusing on what they did create.


I have been a massive Genesis fan for most of my life but have avoided ‘Calling All Stations’ simply due to Collins not being the singer.

I will say Ray Wilson is a damned fine singer and should have been given more time. He fits the music well, but the question is was the music good enough?


The album was very badly received and you can plainly see from the critic reviews that it was a general thumbs-down from the media.


…’was this because Phil Collins was absent from vocal duties or another reason?’…

THREE singles were released from the album all I suppose, designed to be radio-friendly. I am more a fan of the rambling 20-minute tracks of Genesis, but I have to admit they gained their popularity in the 80's due to having great pop songs.

Congo' doesn't really do it for me although it does contain a harder edge from the band than usual.

'Shipwrecked' has some instant appeal but, to be honest, would probably suit the Collins vocal better, and has 'pop' stamped all over it.

Not About Us’ does not sound at all like a Genesis track and is probably the best of the three. Wilson’s vocals do particularly well with this reflective track.

So how about the album tracks so typically the strong point of the band?

There are no massive long songs such as 'Domino' on Calling All Stations, but there are a couple of 7-minute ones.

I did a little research on the internet to find out what others felt about the album tracks on ProgArchives and found a mixture of opinions.


...'Calling All Stations does badly on ProgArchives and is listed as the worst Genesis album ever, I do not agree'...

'The Dividing Line' seems to have some fans, but it didn’t really click with me. Maybe I need to give it a few more listens. I can clearly hear the undertows of Tony Banks, but that kick is missing.

'Small Talk'? Well, it's not as bad as WhoDunnit on the Abacab album, but I would say only a notch up.

The closing track, ‘One Man’s Fool’, did get my interest a little but compared to the old Genesis, didn’t quite do it for me either.

...'give Alien Afternoon a chance to take off, the end is probably it's highlight'...

My pick of the album tracks, no question is ‘Alien Afternoon’, a long song that builds up to a lovely atmospheric finale that you could lose yourself in.

The other song that is worth mentioning is the title track, 'Calling All Stations', which is a driving rock-incuded effort with underlying Banks keyboards.

...'not the Genesis version, but Ray still has it 20 years later, and even more critically still has long hair'...

Overall the album is a little disappointing but I should have given it a listen years ago if only to discover ‘Alien Afternoon'.

Just like the other crap album, they made years before, ‘Abacab’, you can generally find a gem lurking in the depths of the murk.



  • Earn Passive Manna by simply signing up for it here. Mannabase is a Universal Basic Income Cryptocurrency
  • Earn STEEM and digital cards while playing STEEM Monsters, the best game on the STEEM Blockchain here.


Drooling Maniac.JPG

If you found this article so invigorating that you are now a positively googly-eyed, drooling lunatic with dripping saliva or even if you liked it just a bit, then please upvote, comment, resteem, engage me or all of these things.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

I simply cannot comment for fear of offending... :0D

Haha, but he's a Scotsman, one of your clan!

I'm going to admit this is a little before my time, but I enjoyed the music. Thanks for opening me up to something I would not normally listen to!

I guess nobody was really interested in this from the lack of comments, but you are welcome. This is the band at almost their worst!

Not all content is for everyone. I’m trying to branch out and read new content myself. I’ve found that I stuck to a few people. Hive is about building community, exploring new things and making more connections.

Have to say Genesis never did it for me, my step father used to bang on about them and played Duke to death but it never seemed to grab me. Listened to these three tracks and even though my taste has changed over the years they are still not working for me. Cheers for giving me another try though I don't think I would have gone looking by choice. Be safe dude.

I've gotta be honest, I didn't know they continued on after Collins left. For the most part I assumed they just broke up and that was it. I have never heard any of the stuff with this other singer, but I am going to have to check it out now. For better or worse...